Bishops of the Diocese of Erie
The Diocese of Erie was created by papal decree in 1853, and on October 1, 2012, Bishop Lawrence Thomas Persico became the tenth man named as its shepherd. Who were the nine men on whose shoulders he now stands? The Most Rev. Charles Chaput, archbishop of Philadelphia, mentioned them as part of the communion of saints who would be praying for Bishop Persico during his episcopal ordination ceremony.
Father Justin Pino, archivist for the Diocese of Erie, has provided a wealth of personal stories to share about each bishop. These essays provide insight, not only into the life each man led and the work he did for the church in northwest Pennsylvania, but also into how God has provided for our diocese since its earliest days.
- Michael J. O’Connor, D.D. (1810-1872)
- Josue Moody (Joshua Maria) Young (1808-1866)
- Tobias Mullen, D.D. (1818-1900)
- John Edmund Fitzmaurice, D.D. (1837-1920)
- John Mark Gannon, D.D., D.C.L. (1877-1968)
- John Francis Whealon, D.D., S.S.L. (1921-1991)
- Alfred Michael Watson, D.D. (1907-1990)
- Michael Joseph Murphy, D.D. (1915-2007)
- Donald Walter Trautman, S.T.D., S.S.L (1936- )
- Lawrence Thomas Persico (1950- )
Right Reverend Michael J. O’Connor, D.D.
It Is Better to go to the Lions
Bishop Michael O’Connor’s lifelong desire was to become a Jesuit, according to Father Pino. Th e Irish native wanted nothing more than to serve people as a priest and a teacher.“There are many bishops throughout history who were thrust into the episcopacy because of their great knowledge,” he observes. “Bishop O’Connor was smart and caught people’s attention when he was studying in Rome.”
Noting that dioceses were being created very rapidly in 19th century America, Father Pino says Rome looked to Europe for new bishops because there were no native clergy at the time.
“Essentially, the pope needed him,” he explains. So Bishop O’Connor became the bishop of Pittsburgh in 1843. Within a decade, he felt the Diocese of Pittsburgh, which covered the western half of Pennsylvania, was simply too large, so at the Plenary Council of Baltimore in 1852, the Diocese of Erie was created, encompassing the 13 counties of northwest Pennsylvania.
Here, the history becomes a little less clear.
“We’re not sure if he wanted to come to Erie or if he was sent here, but Bishop O’Connor was named as our bishop while Bishop Joshua Young became the bishop of Pittsburgh. Bishop O’Connor arrived in the middle of winter and it’s fair to say it was not a happy experience,” says Father Pino. “You have to remember he was essentially a missionary bishop at that time, living in the wilderness, traveling by horse.”
Bishop O’Connor stayed for only a few months, and there is no record of him having performed any episcopal functions during that time. Somehow, he and Bishop Young were able to essentially trade assignments, and both the bishops and the people of both dioceses were apparently satisfied with the new arrangement.
Happily for Bishop O’Connor, in 1860 he received permission from Rome to retire, at which time he was finally able to become a Jesuit.
“He studied on a fast track and took all four vows at once when he was nearly 60 years old,” says Father Pino. “He taught at Georgetown and on the lecture circuit until his health declined.”
Bishop O’Connor died in 1872, and is buried in a traditional Jesuit grave with his community in Woodstock, Maryland. The cross on his simple gravestone is, however, three inches higher than that of his brothers, indicating that he served as a bishop of the church.